The Nebraska Nugget reported:
About 35 miles northwest of Benkelman, Dundy County, on the 6th of June (1884) a very startling phenomenon occurred. It seems that John W. Ellis and three of his herdsmen and a number of other cowboys were out engaged in a roundup. They were startled by a terrific whirring noise over their heads, and turning their eyes saw a blazing body falling like a shot to Earth. It struck beyond them, being hidden from view by a bank.
One of the herdsmen, Alf Williamson, was burned as he approached the craft, which had created a split in the ground as it dragged to a stop. He was taken back to Ellis' home and treated for his burns.
E.W. Rawlins, the brand inspector for the district, came to inspect it. The Nebraska State Journal reported on the event in 1887, saying: One piece that looked like the blade of a propeller screw, of a metal of an appearance like brass, about 16" wide, 3" thick and 3½' long, was picked up by a spade.
It would not weigh more than 5#, but appeared as strong and compact as any known metal. A fragment of a wheel with a milled rim, apparently having had a diameter of 7' to 8', was also picked up. It seemed to be of the same material and had the same remarkable lightness.
The lack of physical evidence means there's nothing much left today, and John Buder, a field researcher with the Mutual UFO Network of Nebraska, said that the people of Dundy County shy away from talking about the event. Most of his investigation into it has been research. He first stumbled across the story in a tourist's guide to Nebraska. From there, he's found it in multiple books on the subject.
There has been a lot of studies made on UFO crashes, The people who I would claim know the most have not identified it as a hoax.
It was the second UFO crash Buder knows of, and the first to be recorded in newspapers of the time. But once the story came out, it started a worldwide wave of similar stories, some more reputable than others.
One such case is the 1897 crash near Aurora, TX., where four alien bodies are supposedly buried in a graveyard. Eyder Peralta, a reporter for the Houston Chronicle, investigated that crash and turned up nothing.
But the Nebraska crash is the first reported. It was only after the incident near Max that it became a sort of mythology.
That means that all these other hoax crashes that started seem to have gotten their start at Max, NE, Buder said.
It's a piece of Nebraska history only occasionally touched on, Roswell before there was a Roswell to speak of.
I'd say right now there's only a few dozen people in Nebraska who even know about it, Buder said.
But how does a craft just disappear, just dissolve in a crash? What about the cogs that the craft threw off as it approached the ground? Did those, too, simply disappear?
It's a legend taken more seriously than most of the era in ufology circles, which is not to say there aren't skeptics.
But skeptical or not, Buder asserts that it was the beginning of the wave of stories, ground zero for what would turn into airship sightings as time went on. He sees the building of the railroad coinciding with the sightings of the era. In fact, the crafts were often described as railroad engines without wheels at the time.
It's ironic that this same story, this being the first, was repeated many more times worldwide at later dates, Buder said.
And as for the remnants, Buder thinks there might be some things tucked away in the Republican River valley. I wouldn't doubt that out there in one of those tool sheds or barns out there, there's a piece of metal that no one knows where it came from, he said.